PlanAxion weighted scorecard
10 dimensions. 100 points. A defensible decision.
Score every option from 1 to 5 against the same criteria. A score only counts when it is supported by evidence: a demonstration, data, reference, architecture decision or contractual commitment.
Dimension
Weight
What the scorecard measures
Functional fit
20%
Critical process coverage, gap to standard, multi-entity needs and controls.
Industry / operating fit
10%
Manufacturing or distribution depth, planning, inventory and exception handling.
Architecture
10%
Alignment with target architecture, extensibility, security and operability.
Integrations
10%
Critical systems, APIs, EDI, middleware, error handling and customization dependency.
Data
10%
Target data model, migration, quality, governance, reconciliation and validation.
Implementation partner
12%
Actual assigned team, method, relevant experience and knowledge transfer.
Implementation risk
8%
First go-live scope, testing, cutover and critical dependencies.
Adoption
5%
Role impact, super users, training and hypercare.
5-year total cost
10%
Licensing, implementation, extensions, integrations, operations and evolution.
Vendor dependency / contract
5%
Contract flexibility, data access, reversibility and lock-in risk.
1–2Écart important ou preuve faible
3Acceptable avec compromis documenté
4–5Bonne couverture avec preuve claire
RègleUn critère bloquant peut éliminer une solution malgré un bon score total.
![image of success metrics in chart form [interface]](https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/68d6c6b4d43e4325f2d6a40c/692fc5635bfedd1837b55e80_freepik__action-shot-of-a-team-workshop-in-a-glasswalled-me__37767.webp)